It would be nice, but unfortunately many people aren't as open to constructive criticism as others.  (And some aren't as good at the constructive as they are the criticism.)  It would most definitely result in arguments and locked topics.

Jakemaster, you can always go to the "Designer Feedback" forum and post a "review". That is what I do! 

http://www.simviation.com/cgi-bin/yabb/YaBB.cgi?board=designfeedback

Dave

I have to agree -  I recently read the "official" review on site about the Gloster Meteor - it was well done and informative - by someone who seemed to know his subject.   In general the official reviews posted on sites, (assumedly by people who are known and accepted) tend to be positive and supportive.

Over the years I have downloaded many MB's of stuff that I have been disappointed in - my solution has always been to remove it and move on.    If possible, (given the right email urls etc.,) I like to send a thank-you to the designer, pointing out the highlights.

I remember getting a 'review' from someone a while back - using our (??) template - read something like this ...


Visual model : Rocks

Panel: Sucks - default

Sounds : Sucks - default

Air Handling : Rocks

Ground Handling : Rocks

The guy then wrote back to me asking why I hadn't posted it .......

If we could have a way to make one board where mods could approve the post before making it live that would be a good idea .... don't think that can be done with this version of Yabb ....

Quote:


Pete,

I am an artist in life. Do paintings, illustrations, sculpture, photography, etc. I have this happen all the time. Criticism whether good or bad I weigh equally, as some of the negative criticism I receive benefits me in that I strive to get better than I am now. And for all the positive critiques I get, I feel the same way.

There is a difference between knowing who is honest with a critique rather than someone who is talking out of their ###. If I read a review on my artwork where someone says "it sucks" without elaborating why they think that way, its in one ear and out the other. Now if someone says "it sucks. Your composition, and jusxtaposition is wrong, here is why I think so, and while your at it, I think it would have been better if you added this color or that color" with indepth ideas behind the post, I would read it in earnest and consider the critique in a favorable light.