Search the archive:
YaBB - Yet another Bulletin Board
 
   
 
Page Index Toggle Pages: 1
Send Topic Print
Requesting Add-ons: How and Where? (Read 465 times)
Jul 16th, 2007 at 11:12am

Xyn_Air   Offline
Colonel
If I flap my arms fast
enough, I can fly!
Minot, North Dakota

Gender: male
Posts: 621
*****
 
Hello everyone!  Greetings from perhaps your noobiest noob around ("Why is the aircraft screaming to me about 'sink' rate?  We're not on a boat, are we?!?")!

I had a couple of questions about posting requests for add-ons, be it aircraft to airports.  I did notice that there were several forums for said requests with several helpful instructions; I hope you think me neither lazy nor overly bereft of mental faculty ("Hey, which one of these pedals is the gas and which is the brake?") by posting my questions here rather than struggling through elsewhere with previously posted instructions.  My honest intent is not to annoy or take short-cuts ("Checklists are for slow-pokes!"), but simply do my best to get it right the first time.  Rambling explanations aside . . .

1) Is it OK to make requests for specific aircraft skins/repaints?  Presently, I have a great desire for aircraft bearing Northwest Airlines livery, JAL livery, and ANA livery.  Fortunately, there are a lot of add-ons out there with the above liveries, so I am not lacking in options.  But, I was not sure if anyone actually asks for specific repaints in that manner (or if you either just take what is offered or buck-up and learn how to do it yourself).  Furthermore, I have toyed with the idea of having repaints done for my own virtual airline.  I know this sounds pretty bold ("That noob wants his own virtual airline and yet he thinks a stick-shaker is something you make cocktails with!"), but it is a dream of mine.  I wasn't sure if it was in good form to ask around for someone willing to make a custom repaint for your own virtual airline (or, again, if this is something you just learn how to do yourself).

2) Is it OK to offer rewards/incentives to developers willing to make something for you?  I am just not sure how add-on development and copyright law works here.  There may be some instances where I would be willing to offer a reward or incentive (be it monetary or something offered in trade) to a developer who was willing to design a specific add-on for me.  However, I definitely don't want to do anything illegal that could get myself or a developer in trouble.  Is there some sort of licensing guide or information I should be aware of before I offer to pay someone to custom repaint a 747-400 for me?

3) This third question really is an additional question for the two specific examples of add-on request I mentioned above.  First, is requesting a repaint of an aircraft, specifically for your own virtual airline, an appropriate request for the general aircraft requests?  Or, are requests for aircrafts specifically for entire models not yet existent for the game?  (That is, do repaints and custom repaints have their own category?)  Also, is there a difference where you would post an open request for an add-on versus a request for an add-on where you are willing to compensate the developer?

I hope my questions possess some merit and are not too dense in nature.  I thank you all in advance for answers and advice you have to offer.

All the best!
Xyn_Air
 

...
IP Logged
 
Reply #1 - Jul 16th, 2007 at 12:12pm

JBaymore   Offline
Global Moderator
Under the curse of the
hombuilt cockpit!

Gender: male
Posts: 10261
*****
 
Xyn_Air wrote on Jul 16th, 2007 at 11:12am:
1) Is it OK to make requests for specific aircraft skins/repaints?   


Typically, post these kinds of requests in "Aircraft Wanted".  It is always "good form" to do a search of the SimV libraries first to make sure that what you want is not really "obvious".  There a SO many repaints out there that it is hard to imagine that you can't find what you are looking for.  For the commercial airlines you mentioned..... there a tons of repaints.

For requests about doing custom virtual airlines repaints... use the "Virtual Airlines" section devoted to that purpose.  In most cases, virtual airlines are run by multiple people with multiple roles/skills.  As the founder / CEO..... sounds like you need to find a designer/graphic artist as your first virtual employee  Wink.  Right after the virtual lawyer.   Grin  People often ask for folks who want to help in that way.



Xyn_Air wrote on Jul 16th, 2007 at 11:12am:
2) Is it OK to offer rewards/incentives to developers willing to make something for you?  I am just not sure how add-on development and copyright law works here.  There may be some instances where I would be willing to offer a reward or incentive (be it monetary or something offered in trade) to a developer who was willing to design a specific add-on for me.  However, I definitely don't want to do anything illegal that could get myself or a developer in trouble.  Is there some sort of licensing guide or information I should be aware of before I offer to pay someone to custom repaint a 747-400 for me?


You open up an interesting "can of worms" here.  Read the EULA of the product in question and call a lawyer   Wink  Particularly if the repaint is done of a MICROSOFT default plane.  Or any other payware.  

When it comes to a repaint of a freeware plane....... all bets are off.  Not sure HOW that would be treated or looked at by the author of the original freeware aircraft.  Best to ASK that developer first, I guess.

Some people are so "anti payware" that I expect that some developers would not take kindly to that idea of paying someone else to repaint their original efforts.  And some people might feel that it would "tarnish" their selfless acts to the community to overtly accept any form of payment or to let others do so.  But I'd guess some people would feel very happy with such an offer.

Case by case basis, I guess.  
 
Hope this helps.

best,

...................john



 

... ...Intel i7 960 quad 3.2G LGA 1366, Asus P6X58D Premium, 750W Corsair, 6 gig 1600 DDR3, Spinpoint 1TB 7200 HD, Caviar 500G 7200 HD, GTX275 1280M,  Logitec Z640, Win7 Pro 64b, CH Products yoke, pedals + throttle quad, simpit
IP Logged
 
Reply #2 - Jul 16th, 2007 at 12:52pm

Xyn_Air   Offline
Colonel
If I flap my arms fast
enough, I can fly!
Minot, North Dakota

Gender: male
Posts: 621
*****
 
Thanks, John!  Your answers and comments were very helpful indeed!

One thing that did surprise me was that offering to reimburse someone for a repaint might offend the various community developers.  Legal difficulties I expected, but perhaps I was naive about potential social difficulties.

Also, thank you for your comments about virtual airlines and the virtual airline forums.  Though it is somewhere far off for me (perhaps a bit over the simulated horizon), I do have an eventual goal of having a small, virtual airline.  The idea of 'virtual' employees, including a design person or staff, hadn't exactly entered me brain yet.  Great advice!

Thanks, again!

Xyn_Air
 

...
IP Logged
 
Page Index Toggle Pages: 1
Send Topic Print