Search the archive:
Simviation Main Site
|
Site Search
|
Upload Images
Simviation Forum
›
Current Flight Simulator Series
›
Flight School
› Why do planes spin?
(Moderators: Mitch., Fly2e, ozzy72, beaky, Clipper, JBaymore, Bob70, BigTruck)
‹
Previous Topic
|
Next Topic
›
Pages:
1
2
3
4
Why do planes spin? (Read 4144 times)
Oct 19
th
, 2006 at 10:27am
chornedsnorkack
Offline
Colonel
I love YaBB 1G - SP1!
Posts: 363
Why do planes spin?
There is a obvious reason why planes can glide. Translatory flight is stable... with horizontal stabilizer, the airframe will correct changes of angle of attack.
There is an obvious reason why a helicopter rotor might autorotate. At no translational airspeed, every blade is gliding forward, with leading edge in front and trailing edge behind, just as a wing of a fixed-wing plane. Though I cannot see how the AoA would be stabilized... and it is said that helicopters cannot autorotate directly down, but have to gain translational speed if unpowered.
But why do fixed-wing planes spin? Note that the wings have defined, dissimilar leading and trailing edges. In a spin, one wing is moving leading edge forward, the other is moving trailing edge forward. Why is this a stable state? And why cannot a plane in a spin spiral out and return to a forward glide at a reasonable translational speed and low yaw rate?
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #1 -
Oct 19
th
, 2006 at 11:58am
ozzy72
Offline
Global Moderator
Pretty scary huh?
Madsville
Gender:
Posts: 37122
It is a loss of relative airflow over one wing causing a loss of lift. The controls become ineffective and your pants become full
There are two types of aeroplane, Spitfires and everything else that wishes it was a Spitfire!
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #2 -
Oct 19
th
, 2006 at 12:49pm
Brett_Henderson
Offline
Colonel
EVERY OUTER MARKER SHOULD
BE AN NDB
Gender:
Posts: 3593
I depends on the plane. And depends on what type of spin; which can even depend on how the plane is loaded.
There isn't just one answer to that question.
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #3 -
Oct 19
th
, 2006 at 2:15pm
TSC.
Offline
Colonel
The older I get, the better
I was...
Torquay, Devon, England.
Gender:
Posts: 5132
Sometimes it's just down to the girth of your passenger
TSC.
'Only two things are infinite.......The Universe and Human stupidity........and I'm not too sure about the Universe' - Einstein
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #4 -
Oct 19
th
, 2006 at 2:48pm
C
Offline
Colonel
Earth
Posts: 13144
Quote:
Sometimes it's just down to the girth of your passenger
TSC.
You may jest, but sometimes it can be due to the girth of any crew member...
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #5 -
Oct 19
th
, 2006 at 3:37pm
ozzy72
Offline
Global Moderator
Pretty scary huh?
Madsville
Gender:
Posts: 37122
Why do you think I always sit in the middle?
There are two types of aeroplane, Spitfires and everything else that wishes it was a Spitfire!
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #6 -
Oct 19
th
, 2006 at 5:48pm
beefhole
Offline
Colonel
common' yigs!
Philadelphia
Gender:
Posts: 4466
In order for a plane to spin, it must be fully stalled (both wings); but one has to be more stalled than the other, giving a strong turning tendency towards the more stalled wing.
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #7 -
Oct 19
th
, 2006 at 7:08pm
Mobius
Offline
Colonel
Highest Point in the Lightning
Storm
Wisconsin
Posts: 4369
Quote:
In order for a plane to spin, it must be fully stalled (both wings); but one has to be more stalled than the other, giving a strong turning tendency towards the more stalled wing.
Which usually happens when one wing stalls before another, like a stall in a climbing-turn, or in a cross-controlled situation.
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #8 -
Oct 19
th
, 2006 at 8:13pm
beefhole
Offline
Colonel
common' yigs!
Philadelphia
Gender:
Posts: 4466
Quote:
Which usually happens when one wing stalls before another, like a stall in a climbing-turn, or in a cross-controlled situation.
Right, should have clarified that. If one stalls before the other it usually leads to it being MORE stalled than the other. Thanks
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #9 -
Oct 19
th
, 2006 at 8:17pm
Hagar
Offline
Colonel
My Spitfire Girl
Costa Geriatrica
Posts: 33159
Depends on the type of aircraft. Some aircraft tend to drop a wing at the point of stall. This can sometimes be quite violent & easily lead to a spin if not immediately corrected.* There are all sorts of aerodynamic devices to prevent this.
*PS. One classic example is the Bf 109.
Founder & Sole Member - Grumpy's Over the Hill Club for Veteran Virtual Aviators
Member of the
Fox Four Group
Need help? Try
Grumpy's Lair
My photo gallery
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #10 -
Oct 19
th
, 2006 at 8:23pm
beefhole
Offline
Colonel
common' yigs!
Philadelphia
Gender:
Posts: 4466
Quote:
Depends on the type of aircraft. Some aircraft tend to drop a wing at the point of stall. This can sometimes be quite violent & easily lead to a spin if not immediately corrected.* There are all sorts of aerodynamic devices to prevent this.
*PS. One classic example is the Bf 109.
Anyone who's trained in a 172 knows to stomp on the right rudder in a stall.
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #11 -
Oct 19
th
, 2006 at 11:20pm
beaky
Offline
Global Moderator
Uhhhh.... yup!
Newark, NJ USA
Gender:
Posts: 14187
I think the question is more along the lines of: why do airplanes
continue
to spin ("why is this a stable state?").
And I agree that there's no simple answer- planes exhibit a staggering variety of behaviors in a stalled state, and there are many kinds of spins.
But the key to understanding it is to remember that at that point, the shape of the airfoils doesn't matter much, because the airplane is no longer
flying
... it's
falling
. I know a plane can stall "on the upline" and continue to climb (briefly)while spinning, and of course a snap-roll is nothing more than a "horizontal spin", but it's not due to any lifting action of the wings, it's due to momentum.
It's more of a ballistics question than a flight question.
The action of the rudder in reducing or cancelling the spin so that the airfoils and stabs can get the airplane flying again is more like the action of the control surfaces on a rocket or bomb, although generally speaking all the rudder does is move the nose back and forth anyway, even when the plane is flying.
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #12 -
Oct 20
th
, 2006 at 4:29am
chornedsnorkack
Offline
Colonel
I love YaBB 1G - SP1!
Posts: 363
So, how do you design a plane to ensure it returns to flight from a stalled state?
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #13 -
Oct 20
th
, 2006 at 5:19am
Hagar
Offline
Colonel
My Spitfire Girl
Costa Geriatrica
Posts: 33159
Quote:
So, how do you design a plane to ensure it returns to flight from a stalled state?
You make it inherently stable. There are various ways of doing this from using a large dihedral angle to washout on the wingtips. A high-wing type is usually more stable than other types due to the pendulum effect of the low centre of gravity. The shape of the wing is also important & a sharply tapered wing will usually suffer from tip-stall problems.
There are various devices that make the inboard part of the wing nearest the fuselage stall before the tip like the automatic wing slats (used on aircraft like the Bf 109 & Tiger Moth) & small fixed leading edge spoilers as used on the DHC Chipmunk. These are usually fitted to reduce any tip-stall tendencies discovered during initial flight testing of a new type. Some aircraft have been designed from the outset to be impossible (or very difficult) to stall or spin but in most cases this affects performance. If they do happen to spin I wonder how easy it is to recover. One example is the highly efficient wing on the Cirrus SR20/22 series where the recommended spin recovery procedure is to deploy the emergency safety parachute. This will almost certainly damage the aircraft & possibly injure the occupants so the answer is to avoid spinning it if at all possible.
Founder & Sole Member - Grumpy's Over the Hill Club for Veteran Virtual Aviators
Member of the
Fox Four Group
Need help? Try
Grumpy's Lair
My photo gallery
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #14 -
Oct 20
th
, 2006 at 5:57am
chornedsnorkack
Offline
Colonel
I love YaBB 1G - SP1!
Posts: 363
Quote:
You make it inherently stable. There are various ways of doing this from using a large dihedral angle to washout on the wingtips.
Yes, that makes sense - washout means that the wing root stalls first and the plane stalls straight ahead while keeping roll stability, instead of spinning.
Quote:
A high-wing type is usually more stable than other types due to the pendulum effect of the low centre of gravity. The shape of the wing is also important & a sharply tapered wing will usually suffer from tip-stall problems.
Which is probably where washout works.
Quote:
Some aircraft have been designed from the outset to be impossible (or very difficult) to stall or spin but in most cases this affects performance. If they do happen to spin I wonder how easy it is to recover. One example is the highly efficient wing on the Cirrus SR20/22 series where the recommended spin recovery procedure is to deploy the emergency safety parachute. This will almost certainly damage the aircraft & possibly injure the occupants so the answer is to avoid spinning it if at all possible.
For example, T-tails are notorious for deep stalls, even straight ahead. What advantages do they have?
Back to top
IP Logged
Pages:
1
2
3
4
‹
Previous Topic
|
Next Topic
›
« Home
‹ Board
Top of this page
Forum Jump »
Home
» 10 most recent Posts
» 10 most recent Topics
Current Flight Simulator Series
- Flight Simulator X
- FS 2004 - A Century of Flight
- Adding Aircraft Traffic (AI) & Gates
- Flight School ««
- Flightgear
- MS Flight
Graphic Gallery
- Simviation Screenshots Showcase
- Screenshot Contest
- Edited Screenshots
- Photos & Cameras
- Payware Screenshot Showcase
- Studio V Screenshot Workshop
- Video
- The Cage
Design Forums
- Aircraft & 3D Design
- Scenery & Panel Design
- Aircraft Repainting
- Designer Feedback
General
- General Discussion
- Humour
- Music, Arts & Entertainment
- Sport
Computer Hardware & Software Forum
- Hardware
- Tweaking & Overclocking
- Computer Games & Software
- HomeBuild Cockpits
Addons Most Wanted
- Aircraft Wanted
- Other Add-ons Wanted
Real World
- Real Aviation
- Specific Aircraft Types
- Autos
- History
On-line Interactive Flying
- Virtual Airlines Events & Messages
- Multiplayer
Simviation Site
- Simviation News & Info
- Suggestions for these forums
- Site Questions & Feedback
- Site Problems & Broken Links
Combat Flight Simulators
- Combat Flight Simulator 3
- Combat Flight Simulator 2
- Combat Flight Simulator
- CFS Development
- IL-2 Sturmovik
Other Websites
- Your Site
- Other Sites
Payware
- Payware
Old Flight Simulator Series
- FS 2002
- FS 2000
- Flight Simulator 98
Simviation Forum
» Powered by
YaBB 2.5 AE
!
YaBB Forum Software
© 2000-2010. All Rights Reserved.