Search the archive:
Simviation Main Site
|
Site Search
|
Upload Images
Simviation Forum
›
Real World
›
Real Aviation
› Weird Crash
(Moderators: Mitch., Fly2e, ozzy72, beaky, Clipper, JBaymore, Bob70, BigTruck)
‹
Previous Topic
|
Next Topic
›
Pages: 1
Weird Crash (Read 378 times)
Aug 29
th
, 2005 at 5:44pm
Sytse
Offline
Colonel
Virtual Red Arrows
The Netherlands
Gender:
Posts: 3590
Can somebody please tell me what happened here??
It looks really illogical...
http://www.big-boys.com/articles/oldplanecrash.html
&&
Virtual Red Arrows homepage
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #1 -
Aug 29
th
, 2005 at 5:47pm
Woozy King
Ex Member
Forza Lazio!!
Gender:
Gust lock...keeps elevators from moving or something... 8) 8)
&&
SS Lazio Website
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #2 -
Aug 29
th
, 2005 at 5:49pm
Craig.
Offline
Colonel
Birmingham
Gender:
Posts: 18590
Looks to me like the pilot decided to try the short take off procedure went with too high an angle and it didn't work.
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #3 -
Aug 29
th
, 2005 at 7:21pm
beaky
Offline
Global Moderator
Uhhhh.... yup!
Newark, NJ USA
Gender:
Posts: 14187
Cripes, that was awful... wish I hadn't looked.
The Caribou is a venerable old STOL plane; not being an expert, I'd guess runaway trim...
Forgetting to remove the gust lock usually results in an inability to pitch up (the ones i've seen set the elevator at a more or less neutral angle), so I don't think it was that.
It looks like no attempt was made to pitch down and recover, or perhaps it was fitted with electric trim which "ran away" (continued dialing in 'up-trim') and they didn't think to pull the breaker... so despite all their pushing, they couldn't get the nose down. Seems like they did eventually reduce power a little, but it's hard to tell. I think with all that runway ahead, chopping the throttle right away would've been a damn good idea, if one were to think of it.
Might've even been a case of elevator rigging being done backwards after maintenance (I think that plane has mechanical backup as well as hyraulics)... if so, that points out the importance of the pre-takeoff checklist "free and correct" item...
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #4 -
Aug 30
th
, 2005 at 12:48am
SilverFox441
Offline
Colonel
Now What?
Mississauga, Ontario, Canada
Gender:
Posts: 1467
If it wasn't suicide it was a control failure of some sort. A Caribou couldn't have poulled out after that stall...but it could have come very close and pancaked in. There is no noticeable attempt to recover the plane so I have to assume that whatever the pilot was trying just wasn't working.
Steve
(Silver Fox)
Daly
&&
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #5 -
Aug 30
th
, 2005 at 9:47am
RitterKreuz
Offline
Colonel
Texas
Gender:
Posts: 1253
The following quote was taken from the accident investigation performed by the Transportation Safety Board of Canada.
“The accident occurred in August 1992 at the Gimli Industrial Park in Manitoba famous site in Canadian aviation history, where an Air Canada Boeing 767 known as the Gimli Glider was dead-sticked onto a drag racing strip, following fuel exhaustion.
The accident aircraft is a highly modified de Havilland aircraft. In this case a Caribou had been converted to turbine power and was operated under the EXPERIMENTAL category of CAR 4b.
The conversion was accomplished at Gimli, and the aircraft first flew in mid-November 1991, before accumulating about 23 hours on 12 flights by month end. These preliminary tests revealed the need for the replacement of the aircraft’s mechanical vacuum pumps with a Bendix suction system, the addition of in-line fuel boost pumps and the installation of a newly designed hydraulic pump.
The accident occurred on August 27, 1992 on the first of several planned trips to flight check the fuel and hydraulic systems. The aircraft had been hangared in a partially disassembled state over the winter, and had only recently been re-assembled, including the re-installation of the complete tail section.
The accident investigation used this video and some 35mm photographs as a key resource in determining what went wrong at Gimli. With the exception of a slightly higher-than-normal nose attitude at lift-off, the aircraft’s initial climb appeared normal. At about 35 feet AGL, the aircraft made a noticeable pitch up movement.
When I tell you that the photography revealed that the elevator control surfaces were observed to pitch trailing-edge-up for rotation, neutralize and then remain in the neutral position through the balance of that short flight, I expect most of you will come to the same conclusion as the Transportation Safety Board of Canada. The aircraft’s control gust locks were at least partly engaged.”
The full and detailed report is available here
http://www.asasi.org/papers/2001/Four%20Unrelated%20Accidents.pdf
It is several pages long and covers several accidents, refer to page 6, 7 & 8.
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #6 -
Aug 30
th
, 2005 at 11:02am
Sytse
Offline
Colonel
Virtual Red Arrows
The Netherlands
Gender:
Posts: 3590
Wow! You like diggin' up stuff, ey?
Hmmmm... sad accident, but what happened to the crew? Big.boys.com has a policy of not posting videos of people dying...
&&
Virtual Red Arrows homepage
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #7 -
Aug 30
th
, 2005 at 11:05am
RitterKreuz
Offline
Colonel
Texas
Gender:
Posts: 1253
not knowing for sure was bugging the hell out of me
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #8 -
Aug 30
th
, 2005 at 11:07am
Sytse
Offline
Colonel
Virtual Red Arrows
The Netherlands
Gender:
Posts: 3590
I didn't see anyone jump out and looks kind of impossible to survive. Maybe he/she/they got very lucky.
&&
Virtual Red Arrows homepage
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #9 -
Aug 30
th
, 2005 at 11:13am
Saitek
Offline
Colonel
UK
Gender:
Posts: 7555
I wish they didn't post videos of death on that site. No-one could survive that.
Windows 7 Pro 64bit
Intel Core 2 Duo E2180 2GHz
GA-P35-DS3L Intel P35
Kingston HyperX 4GB (2x2) DDR2 6400C4 800Mhz
GeForce 8800 GT 512MB
2 x 22" monitors
200GB Sata
Be Quiet! Straight Power 650W
Flying FSX with Saitek's pro flight range:
Radio
Switch panel
Auto-pilot
Yoke and throttle quad
Pedals
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #10 -
Aug 30
th
, 2005 at 11:27am
Hagar
Offline
Colonel
My Spitfire Girl
Costa Geriatrica
Posts: 33159
First of all I wish I hadn't watched that. Having done so I searched round for more details but couldn't find anything. Thanks to RitterKruez for putting me out of my misery.
Quote:
Hmmmm... sad accident, but what happened to the crew? Big.boys.com has a policy of not posting videos of people dying...
If this is true I think they slipped up on this occasion. I can't see anyone surviving that. I think the report from the link RitterKruez posted confirms it. You don't need an autopsy on survivors.
http://www.asasi.org/papers/2001/Four%20Unrelated%20Accidents.pdf
Quote:
During the post-accident autopsy, a knob from the gust lock handle was found embedded in the captain's right wrist. The TSB concluded that the captain was attempting to operate the gust lock handle when the aircraft hit the ground.
Our expectation was that the pilot flying would have had his hand on the power lever quadrant, which is located immediately aft of the gust lock handle. It is therefore conceivable that, during the impact sequence, his hand might have moved forward, and that this might account for the autopsy finding.
Founder & Sole Member - Grumpy's Over the Hill Club for Veteran Virtual Aviators
Member of the
Fox Four Group
Need help? Try
Grumpy's Lair
My photo gallery
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #11 -
Aug 30
th
, 2005 at 6:11pm
beaky
Offline
Global Moderator
Uhhhh.... yup!
Newark, NJ USA
Gender:
Posts: 14187
Didn't think that of course such a plane might have integral gust locks... what I can't figure is how it didn't occur to the pilot that they might be engaged. Maybe they wouldn't disengage or something.
Still surprised it went up and over like that with neutral elevator, but it's a plane designed for excellent short-field performance, and I guess the engine conversion added some power that helped this disaster unfold.
I agree with those who say no way anyone could have survived... not the way it hit and burned right away. Awful.
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #12 -
Aug 31
st
, 2005 at 3:07pm
Sytse
Offline
Colonel
Virtual Red Arrows
The Netherlands
Gender:
Posts: 3590
It didn't burn right away. If you look closely you can see there's a piece of video missing. When the camera turns away there's no smoke at all and when it goes back up there suddenly is a big black cloud of smoke.
Curious, isn't it?
&&
Virtual Red Arrows homepage
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #13 -
Aug 31
st
, 2005 at 4:31pm
Hagar
Offline
Colonel
My Spitfire Girl
Costa Geriatrica
Posts: 33159
Quote:
It didn't burn right away. If you look closely you can see there's a piece of video missing. When the camera turns away there's no smoke at all and when it goes back up there suddenly is a big black cloud of smoke.
Even if that is the case I don't see how anyone would have survived the impact.
Quote:
Curious, isn't it?
I don't like speculating but as this happened in 1992 I see no harm. From reading the report from RitterKruez's link I have my own theory. The Buffalo/Caribou has a remarkable STOL performance & a steep climb after take-off is normal procedure. Having watched them take off many times I see nothing unusual in the first part of that video. If the gust locks were not properly disengaged (or accidentally engaged during take-off) the elevators would have locked when the controls were returned past the neutral position during the climb out.
Quote:
When I tell you that the photography revealed that the elevator control surfaces were observed to pitch trailing-edge-up for rotation, neutralize and then remain in the neutral position through the balance of that short flight, I expect most of you will come to the same conclusion as the Transportation Safety Board of Canada. The aircraft's control gust locks were at least partly engaged.
Quote:
On the standard Caribou, the gust lock control handle is located forward of the power quadrant, and it has two positions - forward for Unlocked, and aft for Locked.
If the control surfaces are not in the neutral position when the lock is engaged, any movement of the surfaces through the neutral position will cause the lock to engage.
This seems the most logical explanation to me.
Founder & Sole Member - Grumpy's Over the Hill Club for Veteran Virtual Aviators
Member of the
Fox Four Group
Need help? Try
Grumpy's Lair
My photo gallery
Back to top
IP Logged
Reply #14 -
Aug 31
st
, 2005 at 7:55pm
Sytse
Offline
Colonel
Virtual Red Arrows
The Netherlands
Gender:
Posts: 3590
I don't like speculating either, I just thought it was weird.
&&
Virtual Red Arrows homepage
Back to top
IP Logged
Pages: 1
‹
Previous Topic
|
Next Topic
›
« Home
‹ Board
Top of this page
Forum Jump »
Home
» 10 most recent Posts
» 10 most recent Topics
Current Flight Simulator Series
- Flight Simulator X
- FS 2004 - A Century of Flight
- Adding Aircraft Traffic (AI) & Gates
- Flight School
- Flightgear
- MS Flight
Graphic Gallery
- Simviation Screenshots Showcase
- Screenshot Contest
- Edited Screenshots
- Photos & Cameras
- Payware Screenshot Showcase
- Studio V Screenshot Workshop
- Video
- The Cage
Design Forums
- Aircraft & 3D Design
- Scenery & Panel Design
- Aircraft Repainting
- Designer Feedback
General
- General Discussion
- Humour
- Music, Arts & Entertainment
- Sport
Computer Hardware & Software Forum
- Hardware
- Tweaking & Overclocking
- Computer Games & Software
- HomeBuild Cockpits
Addons Most Wanted
- Aircraft Wanted
- Other Add-ons Wanted
Real World
- Real Aviation ««
- Specific Aircraft Types
- Autos
- History
On-line Interactive Flying
- Virtual Airlines Events & Messages
- Multiplayer
Simviation Site
- Simviation News & Info
- Suggestions for these forums
- Site Questions & Feedback
- Site Problems & Broken Links
Combat Flight Simulators
- Combat Flight Simulator 3
- Combat Flight Simulator 2
- Combat Flight Simulator
- CFS Development
- IL-2 Sturmovik
Other Websites
- Your Site
- Other Sites
Payware
- Payware
Old Flight Simulator Series
- FS 2002
- FS 2000
- Flight Simulator 98
Simviation Forum
» Powered by
YaBB 2.5 AE
!
YaBB Forum Software
© 2000-2010. All Rights Reserved.