although Doom 3 was a horrible corridor shooter, just like quake4 and now bioshock, all 3 games never lived up to the hype. Doom3 was fun in a strange "omg this is just doom after surgery" it was horrible and linear but i enjoyed doom3.

bioshock was just such a kick in the balls it was unreal after the hype. and as yahtzee said, it was dumbed down for those who decide to play FPS on consoles

squire 

for anyone interested here is a link to yahtzee's bioshock review. the review is brilliant and i agree with it 100%
Bioshock Review

caution strong language