Search the archive:
YaBB - Yet another Bulletin Board
 
   
 
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print
ADVISE PLS. FAA, CFI (Read 904 times)
Oct 2nd, 2009 at 11:05am

757200ba   Offline
Colonel
757200-THOR of the skys
Florida

Gender: male
Posts: 516
*****
 
Hello.
I have a "question, problem", maybe you guys can clear me and help me.

Im taking my commercial rating.I guess all of you are aware of the requirements for that.
My 'question problem' is this one.you know that we must have min. 250 hours and 50 X country and bla bla!The thing is, i have a portugues glider license, and 375 hours.I know that those hours will count towards my US hours (so i have been told) but there is one thing.I have 75 X country glider hours, i have several check point x country, distance flights and proficience flights most of them with a durations over 4 hours, and some of them with 8 hours in Indurance "mode".

Now the thing is the FAA, states that x country on power airplanes have to be 50 NM and at least with one landing.
And FAA says that gliders x country as to be made in check points method and return to origin airport.

Ok gliders X country dont need to land, they just need to do those checks points flights and return to airport. The same method as in Portugal.

My question is how can i log my glider X country in my commercial, can i do it? How? if possible, i really wanted, not to spend money on X country since i have this hours.Another thing that i dont understand is they say that at least 10 h must be in airplanes, what they mean about it.

Sorry if my English and writing is  confusing.
MANY THANKS Undecided Cry



 
IP Logged
 
Reply #1 - Oct 2nd, 2009 at 2:43pm

Brett_Henderson   Offline
Colonel
EVERY OUTER MARKER SHOULD
BE AN NDB

Gender: male
Posts: 3593
*****
 
If you are preparing for a commercial check-ride.. you, can ask the instructor about what can and can't be logged. And no matter what you can log, you'll still need him to sign you off before you can take the checkride.

So.. the question isn't how much you can log, but if you're ready to take the commercial checkride.

Off the top of my head, I'm going to say that glider x-country time is different than powered x-country time. And some of the manuevers you'll be asked to do, will require lots of practice in the airplane you'll be taking the checkride, in. You aren't goint be able to just jump into a Cessna 182 and fly chandelles (trust me  Wink ) ... and last I checked, a commercial rating requires you to demonstrate an actual spin recovery (though it has been a long time since I took mine).

Anyway you look at it.. you're going to need several hours. You'll have a better feel for it after spending some time in the airplane with an instructor. Don't worry about having enough hours.. worry about being ready to hold a commercial license.
 
IP Logged
 
Reply #2 - Oct 2nd, 2009 at 2:49pm

Mobius   Offline
Colonel
Highest Point in the Lightning
Storm
Wisconsin

Posts: 4369
*****
 
I'm working on my commercial rating too!  So I have a big bookmark right in the FARs (61.129 if you want to read it yourself) on the commercial requirements.

You need 250 total hours with at least 100 hours in powered aircraft and 50 in airplanes, so it sounds like you could use 150 hours of your glider time towards your rating, but you would still need another 150 hours in a powered aircraft (airplane, helicopter, blimp, etc) with at least 50 hours in an airplane.

For the cross country time, you need 50 total hours, 10 of which must be in an airplane, so I would imagine your glider cross country time would work for that as well, since it doesn't specify powered aircraft.

In addition you need to get at least 20 hours of the flying/training that is listed in  FAR 61.129(a)(3).

Double check with your CFI or someone who would know for sure.

EDIT:  Brett beat me too it.  As far as I know, you don't need to demonstrate a spin for the commercial rating, but it's still an excellent idea to know how to recover from one and to even go fly a few with an instructor.  If you're taking your checkride in a 172, you would never finish the checkride if you had to spin it, I don't know anyone that's actually been able to go more than 1/2 turn in a spin without it coming out of it or turning into a spiral. Grin
 

...
IP Logged
 
Reply #3 - Oct 2nd, 2009 at 2:54pm

757200ba   Offline
Colonel
757200-THOR of the skys
Florida

Gender: male
Posts: 516
*****
 
Well from your answer from Brett i know i didnt explain myself right.
What i want to know is if my X country glider hours can be add to the amount i need for the commercial requirements, i know the total time can be add, wich make me around 675 hours total (Glider time plus the power hours i have) so i dont need to worrie about the 250h min you need.I know the concept might be diferent but i think there is a way to consider them.Im aware of the requirements, but i wanted to know if gliders X country hours will count towards the 50 X country PIC you need for commercial.Like you said only 10h need to be in airplanes.But the FAARS also say that need to be at least 2 landings.

And by the way, you can do chandelles on a glider,and lazy eights and eights on pilons too. About the spins, what diference from a power airplane.When a glider spins or stall IT REALY DOES. Wink.But its diferent i know.I done it.
Many Thanks for your help



 
IP Logged
 
Reply #4 - Oct 2nd, 2009 at 4:33pm

Brett_Henderson   Offline
Colonel
EVERY OUTER MARKER SHOULD
BE AN NDB

Gender: male
Posts: 3593
*****
 
I understood your question  Smiley  I was just trying to point out that it wouldn't matter if you had 1,000,000 hours. You're instructor will need to know that you're ready to take the test.

As for X-country hours..  those are for you to gain experience in powered flight-planning (like fuel burns).. navigation.. alternate airports.. all that stuff that doesn't apply to gliding. Your instructor will need to know that you've mastered that stuff..  so you'll be logging some X-country hours, too.

Let us know how it goes  Smiley
 
IP Logged
 
Reply #5 - Oct 2nd, 2009 at 5:05pm

757200ba   Offline
Colonel
757200-THOR of the skys
Florida

Gender: male
Posts: 516
*****
 
Sir with all do respect, i guess you did not understand my question.
My question is:
From my glider hours that i have, plus the X country flight i have.Can i put them into my commercial?
I have at this time 23 X contry PIC im power airplanes , but i have 72 hours Xcountry PIC in gliders.Can they be join as total flight X country for the 50 that is required for the commercial rating?if yes i dont need to be worried on doing time builder, and spend money on X country. Smiley

They told me that flying hours are flying hours and all count as long they are on a personal log book.So i hope they also see that there are X country made, so i can meet the requirements. Wink
And excluding fuel burn, in gliders we also need to have navigation techniques, and alternates to.Using VOR and gps, as navigation too. Cool


 
IP Logged
 
Reply #6 - Oct 2nd, 2009 at 5:28pm

Brett_Henderson   Offline
Colonel
EVERY OUTER MARKER SHOULD
BE AN NDB

Gender: male
Posts: 3593
*****
 
I think it's a language thing   Smiley   I was giving you a round-about answer that it's more about ability, than hours. The hours are a minimum. You could have 500 X-country hours, but not take the test, if you're not ready for it.

Quote:
Can they be join as total flight X country for the 50 that is required for the commercial rating?


My guess is no  Sad   Because you're working on powered-flight, commercial license.. and (as you noted in the first post) those X-country flights need to a minimum of 50nm.
 
IP Logged
 
Reply #7 - Oct 2nd, 2009 at 5:56pm

757200ba   Offline
Colonel
757200-THOR of the skys
Florida

Gender: male
Posts: 516
*****
 
My glider X country are 100km (53.99 nm)-(2h35m)and most of proficience flight are the 100km (i have 6 of those) then i have the 300km (161.93 nm)5h30 , 500km (269 nm) 7h, then i have indurance flights of over than 7 hours and beteen 100 and 200km.
So i guess the 50 nm are cleared, thats why i want to know if they can be add, it would help a lot. Smiley 

About ability, well sir i manage to take my instrument in 29 hours so i guess i have the best instructor, and i guess i know what i do. Wink
 
IP Logged
 
Reply #8 - Oct 2nd, 2009 at 8:21pm

Brett_Henderson   Offline
Colonel
EVERY OUTER MARKER SHOULD
BE AN NDB

Gender: male
Posts: 3593
*****
 
We have a glider pilot here (Rotty), maybe he'll post soon.

I had no idea that you could glide for 50nm  Shocked

Now remember.. it's 50nm in straight-line distance from your departure airport.. NOT 50 nm flown.

I think no matter how you parce this.. you're going to have to log some X-country time.
 
IP Logged
 
Reply #9 - Oct 2nd, 2009 at 8:54pm

757200ba   Offline
Colonel
757200-THOR of the skys
Florida

Gender: male
Posts: 516
*****
 
Well most people dont know you can glide over 200 nm never mind 50.Maybe Rotty can explain that to you.

The fact is, and once again sorry if im being miss understood, so far is just shooting arrows.Maybe you also need some reading, like i do.

I just want to know if i can log my glider X country into my requirements for my commercial.
I dont have any problem on understanding the FAARS the problem is i cant find the criteria to the X country, if they are not made on those they say "at least 10 need to be done in airplane".
The fact is i have 72 X country glider hours and i dont know if i can add them to my current power plane log.
In Portugal they are certified as X country i just want to know if the are valid here.

Many thanks



 
IP Logged
 
Reply #10 - Oct 2nd, 2009 at 10:01pm

Brett_Henderson   Offline
Colonel
EVERY OUTER MARKER SHOULD
BE AN NDB

Gender: male
Posts: 3593
*****
 
OK.. I called my mentor... (30,000 hour, ex AirForce pilot.. 20,000 hours as a CFI)..

He said that X-country time used for a ASEL commercial rating needs to be flights that include a landing at an airport at least 50nm away.
 
IP Logged
 
Reply #11 - Oct 2nd, 2009 at 11:22pm

757200ba   Offline
Colonel
757200-THOR of the skys
Florida

Gender: male
Posts: 516
*****
 
Like i said on my first post.

But, they say 10 must be done in airplanes, they dont say where the others can be done.Thats whay i think i can add mine made in glider.I know you can log 30 in simulator, but what about the rest?Can they be used the ones made in diferent categories?In glider we also do that, we mark distance in map and we fly chek points, but without landing, we have to return to the origin airport.
Snce the bigginig thats my question.
Thank you for checking, thank you very much.I guess i can log my total, and foirget the X country ones.
Many thanks sir,  for your help. Undecided Embarrassed Cry Wink


 
IP Logged
 
Reply #12 - Oct 3rd, 2009 at 6:53pm

beaky   Offline
Global Moderator
Uhhhh.... yup!
Newark, NJ USA

Gender: male
Posts: 14187
*****
 
757200ba wrote on Oct 2nd, 2009 at 11:22pm:
Like i said on my first post.

But, they say 10 must be done in airplanes, they dont say where the others can be done.


The FARs say "100 hours in powered aircraft, of which 50 hours must be in airplanes".
This means if you have helicopter, gyroplane, or airship time, it counts towards the "100 hours in powered aircraft". But gliders do not count towards the "50 in airplanes".


Remember: THE FAA DOES NOT USE THE WORD "AIRPLANE" WHEN REFERRING TO GLIDERS!!!! IF YOU SEE THE WORD "AIRPLANE" (NOT "AIRCRAFT") IN THE FARS, THEY ARE TALKING ABOUT POWERED AIRPLANES, NOT GLIDERS.
You and I know that gliders are airplanes, but the FAA has its own special definition of what an "airplane" is.


Quote:
Thats whay i think i can add mine made in glider.I know you can log 30 in simulator, but what about the rest?Can they be used the ones made in diferent categories?


More from the FARs:

"You must log at least 250 hours of flight time as a pilot (of which 50 hours, or in accordance with FAA Part 142, a maximum of 100 hours may have been accomplished in an approved flight simulator or approved flight training device that represents a single engine airplane)."


So, it's 50 or maybe 100 hours of sim time allowed (FAA-approved sims), and yes, when it comes to your total PIC time, gliders (and all other categories of aircraft) count.
But gliders do NOT count when it comes to the "50 in airplanes", or "100 in powered aircraft".



The other problem here, as Brett pointed out, is that the FAA defines "cross country" flights, for the purpose of any powered aircraft rating, as being a flight to an airport 50 miles away from the departure airport, with a landing at that airport.   Think of it less in terms of distance covered, and more in terms of making a flight- with a landing- to some point outside a 49 nm-radius circle of the starting point.


Believe me, I know that 50 nm in a glider requires considerable airmanship, but the FAA does not see that as being equal to landing at another airport 50 miles away.
A commerical glider pilot's rating is very respectable, too, but the FAA doesn't care about that when it comes to even the most rudimentary powered-aircraft commercial flight.

I know, it's silly... but it's the FAA. Grin

At least you can count your glider time towards your total time!  Smiley
And because you are a glider pilot, you will probably do better on the maneuvers portion of your CP-ASEL check ride than most non-glider pilots. Grin

Good luck!!
 

...
IP Logged
 
Reply #13 - Oct 3rd, 2009 at 7:44pm

beaky   Offline
Global Moderator
Uhhhh.... yup!
Newark, NJ USA

Gender: male
Posts: 14187
*****
 
Brett_Henderson wrote on Oct 2nd, 2009 at 8:21pm:
We have a glider pilot here (Rotty), maybe he'll post soon.

I had no idea that you could glide for 50nm  Shocked




Ha!

50 nm ain't nothing, even from a low tow...remember, a glider pilot, instead of having an engine, relies on knowledge of how to exploit the atmosphere's energy. And there's a lot of energy up there...

The world records for gliding distance achievements are complicated by the multitude of glider classes and flight types (out and back, multi-point course, etc), but just to give you an idea, the current US record  for a "free 3-point turnaround distance", in the "open" class, in a SGS 1-26 just like our club's 1-seater, is 579 miles!! The pilot, Ronald Schwartz, did it out of Blairstown, NJ, using thermals and ridge lift along the mountains to the west. He was aloft for 12 hours!!!

The glider altitude record, BTW, from a 13,000 MSL tow in the Andes, is over 50,000 MSL! Over 1.5 hours above 40,000!!  Steve Fossett and Einar Enevoldson did that in a modified DG-500, taking advantage of an elusive effect created by polar air flow and the jet stream interacting with the high mountains. They said they could have gone higher (they were hoping for 100,000 MSL) and stayed up longer if the pressure suits hadn't hampered their movements so much! Cheesy


On a more mundane level, I have flown solo in the 2-33 for about an hour(off a 2000 MSL tow)... at an average speed of about 50 mph, that's almost 50 nm covered., albeit not in a straight line, and constantly climbing or descending. I could have stayed up longer but didn't want to hog the trainer that day. When I get into the 1-26 and start really working on X-C stuff, you'll see much more impressive results.
Our club's most accomplished soaring pilot does very well with our two ships- we don't get any terrain-induced lift around here, but he's gone all the way to the Delaware
River and back (over 60nm total).
The ridge lift is actually pretty good over there (near Blairstown)... there's a lot of potential gliding out of 47N, if you get a good day and know what you're doing.
 

...
IP Logged
 
Reply #14 - Oct 3rd, 2009 at 8:37pm

757200ba   Offline
Colonel
757200-THOR of the skys
Florida

Gender: male
Posts: 516
*****
 
Its always a pleasure to know "'condors".
Most o f my flight time was made (and i havent flown a glider in 6 years)in ASW 20 (monoplace) and Grob Twin Astir (dual) and i have 4 hours on a Glaser-Dirks DG-100 ( the klast one i "had fun").And ofcourse most of my instruction was on the good old Blanick L-13 (what a lovely bird).

In my time my Xcountry were made in Portugal.With the weather and mountains we have you could go from north to south in last than 8 hours, in good conditions.Most of them were made by reporting points with ID from the ground, its not a big country so everybody use to fly the same courses.

The thing about all my questions is, even after you explanation there is one thing that or its not correct.This are the comercial req.

250 Hours minimum total flight time experience which includes:
      100 hours powered aircraft
       50 hours in airplanes
       50 hours of cross country flight time
            10 hours of which must be in airplanes

       20 hours of flight training
       10 hours instrument training
        5 hours in single engine airplanes
       10 hours training in complex or turbine

    1 daytime cross country VFR flight of at least 2 hours and 100 NM leg length
    1 night night time cross country VFR flight of at least 2 hours and 100 NM leg length

    3 hours of test prep in a single engine airplane within the preceding
        60 days prior to practical test

   10 hours solo flight time (after having attained a Private Pilot Certificate), including:

       1 solo cross country flight of at least 300 NM w/ 3 points one at least one 250 NM leg
       5 hours night solo w/ 10 takes offs & landings at airport w/ operating control tower

as you see 50 hours are requiered for Xcountry, but only 10 must be in airplanes.

Today i spoke with and FAA guy and he told me something interesting.
Ofcourse he told me that all my hours will count towards the total time.But if i go to one of the FAA oficees they can take some of X country time and add to towards the x country time, since my hours are all certified. and some of them are descreminated on distance (like 300km, 500km trip, endurance gain not just in high but with total distance).He told me that they might consider those (wich make around 27 hours) but all the other X country i made they might just consider to total time.
I have 72 hours x country, with those i loose 45 hours but if i add this 27 to the 23 that i have, it will make  exact 50 h x country.So that makes me happy.
He also told me that it depends alot, and the FAARS are not very exact when it cames to this kind of cases.

So i will try to do it.

Many thanks to all of you i will keep you posted.
Thank you Smiley





« Last Edit: Oct 4th, 2009 at 12:31am by 757200ba »  
IP Logged
 
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print