Search the archive:
YaBB - Yet another Bulletin Board
 
   
 
Pages: 1 2 3 
Send Topic Print
Complete Newbie...and it shows (aka I'm a moron) (Read 3586 times)
Reply #15 - Feb 8th, 2008 at 12:54pm

Brett_Henderson   Offline
Colonel
EVERY OUTER MARKER SHOULD
BE AN NDB

Gender: male
Posts: 3593
*****
 
Yeah... that big, notched wheel is for rough calibrating the hardware itself... nothing to do with in-flight trim  Wink

I don't fly the big jets at all, so I'll have to guess that maybe the autopilot is on ?

I'll go fly it now.. see what happens..
 
IP Logged
 
Reply #16 - Feb 8th, 2008 at 1:00pm

Alrot   Ex Member
I Love Simviation.

*
 


I would like to add one thing, RudeandRude You are not Moron , We do not consider moron anybuddy ,well exept those whos been in this microsoft flight simulator for almost a decade ,with us and ask How do I install a plane Grin You are in very good hands here ,feel welcome ,follow the rules, ,and we are going to help you in anything you need to know in MSFSX.. Wink
 
IP Logged
 
Reply #17 - Feb 8th, 2008 at 1:33pm

Brett_Henderson   Offline
Colonel
EVERY OUTER MARKER SHOULD
BE AN NDB

Gender: male
Posts: 3593
*****
 
Welllll    T H A T  was interesting  Huh

It must be the Airbus fly-by-wire deal. I'm not jet expert, so I don't know how realistic it is. But it seems you don't need to adjust pitch trim. If you're just flying along and gently change pitch, it's like a computer takes over and locks in on that pitch angle. The manual trim is useles.. but oddly enough.. if you turn the autopilot ON, you can adjust pitch with the trim wheel...  very strange. Also the rudder is functionless in flight UNTIL you're near the ground and near landing speed.. which is OK (I guess), so long as the fly-by-wire coordinates turns (and it seems to)... because you don't need independent rudder control until you need to cross-control a little, landing in a cross-wind.. (I don't think slipping jets down to a runway is a good idea.. even if you can)..

I'm a light piston pilot..  so I'll defer to the jet experts.. I have to admit though.. if you get use to this auto-trim stuff, it can be pretty handy landing a big, heavy tube  Cheesy
 
IP Logged
 
Reply #18 - Feb 8th, 2008 at 1:37pm

RudeandRude   Offline
Colonel
Hello!
New York

Gender: male
Posts: 63
*****
 
Ive been away for the past day and a half but I'l get back into it tonight.  I definitely just need practice. 

Is there anywhere in the game that shows you how many hours you;ve logged total?
 
IP Logged
 
Reply #19 - Feb 8th, 2008 at 4:40pm

bpops   Offline
Lieutenant Colonel
Disallow linked images
if they're not allowed.

Posts: 8
*****
 
Brett,

Ok, good, it's not just me then Tongue

I did notice that it seemed to keep its pitch better, but you have to push or pull quite a bit on the yoke to 'disengage' this fly-by-wire or whatever it is. Maybe it will help with those big jets, but I'm used to the smaller planes for now.

RudeandRude,

In the main FSX window, click 'Pilot Records' then the 'Logbook' tab.
 
IP Logged
 
Reply #20 - Feb 8th, 2008 at 7:32pm

RudeandRude   Offline
Colonel
Hello!
New York

Gender: male
Posts: 63
*****
 
I know I need to have patience but holy crap this is frustrating.  I just did the training mission where I am first flying the Jetliner.  I'm in mid-flight and struggling with my climb/decent the entire 20 minutes.  One second I'm descending at 1200 feet per minute, I click one tiny click trim up and within 15 seconds I'm climbing at 1200 feet per second.

For some reason in this jet when I leave the stick at neutral position I just start climbing at a 30 degree climb pretty much right after takeoff, with all flaps at normal.  I have to push the stick almost all the way up (nose down) just to keep level flight.  Is that normal in a Bombardier CRJ700 ?
 
IP Logged
 
Reply #21 - Feb 8th, 2008 at 9:58pm

RudeandRude   Offline
Colonel
Hello!
New York

Gender: male
Posts: 63
*****
 
does anyone know how I record a video?  The help section says to "go into the options menu" but I dont even know how to get to the options menu!
 
IP Logged
 
Reply #22 - Feb 8th, 2008 at 11:07pm

congo   Offline
Colonel
Make BIOS your Friend
Australia

Gender: male
Posts: 3663
*****
 
RudeandRude wrote on Feb 8th, 2008 at 7:32pm:
I just did the training mission where I am first flying the Jetliner.  I'm in mid-flight and struggling with my climb/decent the entire 20 minutes.  One second I'm descending at 1200 feet per minute, I click one tiny click trim up and within 15 seconds I'm climbing at 1200 feet per second.

For some reason in this jet when I leave the stick at neutral position I just start climbing at a 30 degree climb pretty much right after takeoff, with all flaps at normal.  I have to push the stick almost all the way up (nose down) just to keep level flight.  Is that normal in a Bombardier CRJ700 ?


It's best to stick with the cessna until you get the hang of it unless you just want to burn around in jets,...... you'll learn more in a slower plane, things don't happen so fast.

Your up and down meanderings are normal, it's difficult to establish a constant climb rate, particularly on jets.

The problem is trim, you still need lots of practice, and when I saw you post a couple days back after a few minutes of trying, you said "I definitely understand trim" ...... I knew you had a ways to go Smiley

Let's put it into perspective...... It tooks me YEARS to get my Airline pilot's license in Flight Simulator. So if you are looking for a one week wonder, this is probably the wrong game for you.

To understand trim, you need to appreciate the dynamics of flight and how planes actually fly, this may appear simple at first, but there are really a lot of things to consider, more than the layman, or even many pilots realise.

I won't scare you with stories of "getting behind the drag curve" but there is a lot about aviation that the novice cannot possibly be aware of.

With trim, the dynamics are mainly concerned with relationships between power and pitch settings, which in turn affects airspeed.

Those three things are under your control and you CAN balance the plane without trim, albeit, only at a very limited pitch and speed range.

Trim allows you to fly a balanced aircraft at various speed and pitch settings. When you pitch, you will alter speed unless you alter power setting.

When you alter power setting, you will alter the pitch angle. Airspeed is a function of the other two elements.

If you see the speed increasing, the pitch will climb, because the wing produces more lift, and the opposite occurs if you reduce speed.

As far as Flight Sim concerns you as a noob pilot, you only need to use the trim for balance at first, that is enough.


Here is an exercise for you.

Try a Free Flight of your choice, level out at 3000'ft and 110kts in the plain old Cessna 172. Trim until you can release the stick and the plane holds 3000'steady, use power adjustments to maintain 110kts, trimming for level flight as required.

This could take a while, just practice it until you can repeat it on demand. Use the Variometer to determine your rate of climb or sink and that can be a guide to help you know if you are flying perfectly level.

Repeat the exercise but instead of 110kts, use an engine rpm setting as a constant, say, 2200rpm.

Note the effect of speed and power changes on your attitude once trimmed for level flight.

From here, you can experiment with a myriad of flap settings, power settings, pitch angles etc, to see how they all affect trim.

There is a correct trim for every situation (within normal flight envelopes).

You can leave the trim alone and climb up, and then adjust power to fly level, the plane will be in "level flight trim" for that power setting.

RudeandRude wrote on Feb 8th, 2008 at 9:58pm:
does anyone know how I record a video?  The help section says to "go into the options menu" but I dont even know how to get to the options menu!


Hit ALT in flight and you'll see a menu bar appear at top of screen, select options/Flight Videos

Edit:
A note on Autopilot. The autopilot will trim the aircraft normally. Using autopilot will not allow you to consider the effects or understand trim, leave it off during the learning stage until you master the "Art of Trimming"  Wink
 

...Mainboard: Asus P5K-Premium, CPU=Intel E6850 @ x8x450fsb 3.6ghz, RAM: 4gb PC8500 Team Dark, Video: NV8800GT, HDD: 2x1Tb Samsung F3 RAID-0 + 1Tb F3, PSU: Antec 550 Basiq, OS: Win7x64, Display: 24" WS LCD
IP Logged
 
Reply #23 - Feb 8th, 2008 at 11:38pm

RudeandRude   Offline
Colonel
Hello!
New York

Gender: male
Posts: 63
*****
 
Yeah I guess you're right, I need to do some free flights for now.  I didn't even see that was an option until you mentioned it.  I thought it was just missions.  Cool.
 
IP Logged
 
Reply #24 - Feb 9th, 2008 at 12:14am

Brett_Henderson   Offline
Colonel
EVERY OUTER MARKER SHOULD
BE AN NDB

Gender: male
Posts: 3593
*****
 
Hey Congo...  when are we gonna see you in the Sim Flight Training ?

Good discussions going on there... All the parts (1-7) are posted now... and we'll be doing FSX shared-cockpit checkrides soon.  Smiley

On that note, I'm compelled to point out a couple things. I know what you were trying to say, but wording can be critical at this point in the learning curve.

Quote:
If you see the speed increasing, the pitch will climb, because the wing produces more lift, and the opposite occurs if you reduce speed.


If you just SEE airspeed increasing, and haven't changed the power setting; you're definately descending. If  YOU  increase the power setting from level flight, airspeed will initially rise and THAT will cause a slight pitch up, and a gain in altitude, and then the airspeed will come back down. Conversely, if you just SEE the airspeed decreasing (with no power change), that means you're climbing.

When you say, "reduce speed", that confuses me too. If you mean to reduce power, then yes; airspeed will drop off a bit, but not much if that's all you do.. because you'll start descending.

The reason this is confusing when talking about trimming ?  Consider that you're flying along , pitching/trimmimg to stay level, not touching the throttle. If the airspeed starts decreasing, that means you're climbing... and if the airspeed increases, and that means you're descending. That's why the airspeed indicator is your first reference, and the vertical speed indicator (variometer ?) is your last reference for trimming.. mainly because it's usually several seconds behind what's really happening and you can end up chasing it.

Your primary instruments for pitching/trimming  (assuming a fixed power setting) are the altimeter and the airspeed indicator. Airspeed indicator first and foremost when climbing (pitching for best rate of climb).... Altimeter first and foremost when leveling off (getting it to stop on the desired altitude, and then using the airspeed indicator to determine when to reduce to cruise power)... THEN, if need be, fine tuning the trim by the vertical speed indicator.

Now.... lol .. if we're all as confused as I am... go back to something Congo said earlier, because it's the basic truth..

Quote:
The idea of trim is to reduce stick or yoke loads to reduce pilot fatigue.


Carve that in stone..  You aren't supposed to "fly" with the trim, at all  Smiley


 
IP Logged
 
Reply #25 - Feb 9th, 2008 at 2:20am

RudeandRude   Offline
Colonel
Hello!
New York

Gender: male
Posts: 63
*****
 
Ok so I started a free flight from North Las Vegas Airport to Henderson Executive in the Cessna 172.

I figured out the Air Traffic Controller stuff, which was pretty cool.  I take off.  Awesome, doing great.  I was able to trim the climb so that I could completely take my hands off the stick and it was climbing at around 75 kias.  Perfect.

But then I realized the problem....where the heck am I going????  In the missions it had that little compass in the upper left hand corner that gave me visual clues as to where my next waypoint is.  Now I have no visual help.  I dont even know if I'm going in the right direction.  I did set up waypoints and just assumed that they would show up.

I brought up the GPS but that didnt help.  I brought up the map but couldnt even find Henderson on it. 

Can anyone help me out?  I saw there was an option called Visual Flight Path, so I enabled that, set it to Nav 1 and then turned on Nav1 but I still saw nothing.

 
IP Logged
 
Reply #26 - Feb 9th, 2008 at 2:36am

bpops   Offline
Lieutenant Colonel
Disallow linked images
if they're not allowed.

Posts: 8
*****
 
Rude,

Click 'Learning Center', then the "Lessons" tab at the top, and start doing all the courses. You mentioned before that you were doing these, but if you really did them, it does tell you how to navigate your way both visually and with instruments. 

Just spend some time with those built-in courses, (and read the ground school!). They really are as close as you can get to having a flight instructor without paying for one  Wink
 
IP Logged
 
Reply #27 - Feb 9th, 2008 at 2:44am

RudeandRude   Offline
Colonel
Hello!
New York

Gender: male
Posts: 63
*****
 
I've completed the first 6 lessons.  The free flight was HUGE in getting me to have some kind of handle on the trim.  I'll go back into lesson mode for the time being.
 
IP Logged
 
Reply #28 - Feb 9th, 2008 at 5:08am

congo   Offline
Colonel
Make BIOS your Friend
Australia

Gender: male
Posts: 3663
*****
 
Brett_Henderson wrote on Feb 9th, 2008 at 12:14am:
Hey Congo...  when are we gonna see you in the Sim Flight Training ?

Good discussions going on there... All the parts (1-7) are posted now... and we'll be doing FSX shared-cockpit checkrides soon.  Smiley

On that note, I'm compelled to point out a couple things. I know what you were trying to say, but wording can be critical at this point in the learning curve.

Quote:
If you see the speed increasing, the pitch will climb, because the wing produces more lift, and the opposite occurs if you reduce speed.


If you just SEE airspeed increasing, and haven't changed the power setting; you're definately descending. If  YOU  increase the power setting from level flight, airspeed will initially rise and THAT will cause a slight pitch up, and a gain in altitude, and then the airspeed will come back down. Conversely, if you just SEE the airspeed decreasing (with no power change), that means you're climbing.

When you say, "reduce speed", that confuses me too. If you mean to reduce power, then yes; airspeed will drop off a bit, but not much if that's all you do.. because you'll start descending.


I'll have a look at the sim training if I get time Brett, thanks for the invite.

I knew when I posted that blog that I'd get into trouble with it Smiley

You see, I do know my stuff, but communicating it quickly into text is not my forte, it takes me eons to write a simple airplane install "how-to", let alone explain the finer points of trimming an aircraft. I apologise for my brevity and inaccuracies. I was frantically trying to get that VP-2 aircraft mod finished today so I can move on to more important projects.

Set in stone huh? Well, in the real world, things are not always that way. You can hit a thermal or orographic or shear wave and fly into lift that will give an airspeed increase or decrease when you hit sink, but that's not what I was referring to. I meant that a power increase had not taken effect as yet, so you would see the speed and attitude rising.

Most of my real life flying is in unpowered sailplanes, so pitch is speed control, not power settings, I tend to think in terms of pure aerodynamics without the power equation at first, then I need to think of thrust adjustment, because it's not a luxury I'm used to, despite my thousands of hours simming powered planes. So, you see, I need to consider things more carefully before commenting  Tongue

I don't want to get caught up in the semantics, it's counter productive so I'll butt out.

You are quite correct of course in pointing out the importance of learning the basics correctly without me adding more confusion into the bargain.

My first flight instructor was well aware of this phenomenon of first learned knowledge, it's primal and tends to stick like glue. Best not to form bad habits early.

I made a comment about flying on trim earlier as well, I should not have done that. It's ok for us old timers who have hundreds or thousands of hours on type, we know a notch of trim here or there will produce a certain effect, but your right in advising not to fly on trim.

I have probably trained around thirty people on simulators, and about half that many in aircraft once they passed their basic training in gliders. (I was sort of our club's "Cross country coach" in an unofficial capacity, all the students wanted to soar for hours like me lol).

It's a lot easier to do in real life where the effects are felt and seen in the real world. It's also amazing to see what turns up in the students heads, they can have some BAD misconceptions about certain aspects of flight that weren't picked up in their basic training.

Just as a point of interest, my left hand rarely leaves the trim knob on sailplane flights Brett, I look at trim as a throttle of sorts. Wierd huh? I've even told passengers that the green knob is the throttle, and then they start looking around for an engine Cheesy
 

...Mainboard: Asus P5K-Premium, CPU=Intel E6850 @ x8x450fsb 3.6ghz, RAM: 4gb PC8500 Team Dark, Video: NV8800GT, HDD: 2x1Tb Samsung F3 RAID-0 + 1Tb F3, PSU: Antec 550 Basiq, OS: Win7x64, Display: 24" WS LCD
IP Logged
 
Reply #29 - Feb 9th, 2008 at 9:31am

Brett_Henderson   Offline
Colonel
EVERY OUTER MARKER SHOULD
BE AN NDB

Gender: male
Posts: 3593
*****
 
Yeah... learning to fly (even in a sim) from complete ground zero is a tough and confusing thing. The best hope to get it quickly is to focus on the basics.. and then develop bad habits on your own  Cheesy

Consider student flight planning. You're forced to calculate an EXACT heading and ground speed, allowing for winds aloft; magnetic variation; and compass errors... then take this information and calcualte exact fuel burns, so that you can take your tediously calculated weight-and-balance and see if your exact fuel load is withing weight limits.. allowing for a certain fuel reserve.  Shocked

On paper that's all well and good... but there aint a pilot alive who can hold an exact heading.. and no winds aloft forcast is accurate enough so that your calculations are worthy of all that effort. And if you ever DO  takeoff on a flight where you'd use the fuel up exactly.... that calculated reserve had better be on the high side  Wink

The reason students are put through that drill, is so that the whole concept and big picture get hammered into their subconcious. Some people have that thought process as a genetic gift. But for training purposes.. you have to assume the student's aviation brain is a blank slate. Some students will breeze through flight planning training, like a formality.. it just makes sense to them. Some will struggle with an E6B, a calculator, a weight-and-balance sheet, for weeks until it clicks.

Same for flying the plane itself. I was an instructor for a while and even during my brief tenure, I saw it all. One student will get the lift/thrust/drag/gravity concept like it's no big deal.. makes perfect sense to him. The next student will make your hair turn white, as you have to keep telling him NOT to bank more than 30 degrees at pattern altitude at pattern airspeed. Explaining an accelerated stall to the first student is as easy as saying, "1+1=2"... to the other student, it's an abstract thing. The first time student one is asked to enter a power-on stall... all you have to do is watch.. he knows what's happening and recovers effortlessly. Student two will put you on the edge of a stall spin  Shocked.  Student one instinctively holds the nose down when rolling out of a turn.. Student two is all over sky.

Bottom line though... both students need to be sound, fudementally. It's OK to fly by the trim wheel. I do it all the time. Some situations actually call for it. But when your teaching this stuff to someone completely new and blank.. you can't stray from the basics. Like you said.. the first learned knowledge is hard to displace.
 
IP Logged
 
Pages: 1 2 3 
Send Topic Print