Search the archive:
YaBB - Yet another Bulletin Board
 
   
 
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print
Yet, another WWII question (Read 886 times)
Reply #15 - Dec 21st, 2005 at 10:33am

Hagar   Offline
Colonel
My Spitfire Girl
Costa Geriatrica

Posts: 33159
*****
 
Quote:
I'm aware that the folks at Bletchly park were very good at their business of reading German codes, but that doesn't mean the Japanese weren't sending their info to Tokyo and the allies weren't reading those messages.

I don't know the facts in this specific case as I'd not heard of it before but it's quite likely that those messages you refer to were passed direct to the Japanese section at Bletchley Park for deciphering. As I pointed out earlier, this included a large American contingent. I only discovered this during my recent visit as it was never common knowledge. Everything done at Bletchley during WWII was classified as Top Secret & some still is today. Lack of knowledge of what was actually achieved there (like the development of the first electronic computer) has led to many misconceptions since the war. All equipment & documents were destroyed soon after the end of WWII to prevent it falling into the hands of a potential enemy. I don't expect this is unique by any means & there are some things that will never be revealed, at least during my lifetime.
 

...

Founder & Sole Member - Grumpy's Over the Hill Club for Veteran Virtual Aviators
Member of the Fox Four Group

Need help? Try Grumpy's Lair

My photo gallery
IP Logged
 
Reply #16 - Dec 21st, 2005 at 10:47am

Woodlouse2002   Offline
Colonel
I like jam.
Cornwall, England

Gender: male
Posts: 12574
*****
 
Quote:
You're free to be sceptical, but scepticism doesn't change the facts.  I'm aware that the folks at Bletchly park were very good at their business of reading German codes, but that doesn't mean the Japanese weren't sending their info to Tokyo and the allies weren't reading those messages.

I'm not saying that isn't the case. What I'm saying is that the chances are that the infomation didn't have to come from Tokyo and any that did would have been used to support what had already come from deciphered German transmissions.

It is true that there was an american team at Bletchley Park. This was no doubt a move to encourage the allies to share their intelligence as the British could easily have kept what they were doing to themselves.
 

Woodlouse2002 PITA and BAR!!!!!!!!&&&&Our Sovereign Lord the King chargeth and commandeth all persons, being assembled, immediately to disperse themselves, and peaceably to depart to their habitations, or to their lawful business, upon the pains contained in the Act made in the first year of King George the First for preventing tumults and riotous assemblies. God Save the King.&&&&Viva la revolution!
IP Logged
 
Reply #17 - Dec 21st, 2005 at 11:04am

Hagar   Offline
Colonel
My Spitfire Girl
Costa Geriatrica

Posts: 33159
*****
 
Quote:
It is true that there was an american team at Bletchley Park. This was no doubt a move to encourage the allies to share their intelligence as the British could easily have kept what they were doing to themselves.

Woody. I should remind you that this was a combined operation. The invasion & liberation of Europe would have been impossible without the considerable contribution of American forces & equipment and I imagine intelligence. It's quite natural that any intelligence would be passed on to the appropriate area without worrying if this happened to be American or British or even Russian if affected them. It's also quite likely that those Japanese messages were deciphered at Bletchley Park as this was in the area involved & also the centre of Allied codebreaking throughout WWII. The intelligence belonged to the Allied effort & not one country & I suspect it was all passed through the same chain of command to whoever was responsible for distributing it.

I realise that inter-service rivalry caused a lot of problems during WWII & have no doubt this also applied to international cooperation but it would have been so much easier without these petty squabbles. We were all on the same side. Roll Eyes
 

...

Founder & Sole Member - Grumpy's Over the Hill Club for Veteran Virtual Aviators
Member of the Fox Four Group

Need help? Try Grumpy's Lair

My photo gallery
IP Logged
 
Reply #18 - Dec 21st, 2005 at 11:16am

Woodlouse2002   Offline
Colonel
I like jam.
Cornwall, England

Gender: male
Posts: 12574
*****
 
Quote:
Woody. I should remind you that this was a combined operation. The invasion & liberation of Europe would have been impossible without the considerable contribution of American forces & equipment and I imagine intelligence. It's quite natural that any intelligence would be passed on to the appropriate area without worrying if this happened to be American or British. It's also quite likely that those Japanese messages were deciphered at Bletchley Park as this was in the area involved & also the centre of Allied codebreaking throughout WWII.

I realise that inter-service rivalry caused a lot of problems during WWII & have no doubt this also applied to international cooperation but it would have been so much easier without these petty squabbles. We were all on the same side. Roll Eyes

I am fully aware of that but countries are bound to keep secrets from their allies even in a war that depends on full cooperation.  All I was saying was that the Americans came to Bletchley partle because they wanted in on the act and also as a gesture of trust as their efforts at breaking the German codes hadn't amounted to nearly as much success as the British.
 

Woodlouse2002 PITA and BAR!!!!!!!!&&&&Our Sovereign Lord the King chargeth and commandeth all persons, being assembled, immediately to disperse themselves, and peaceably to depart to their habitations, or to their lawful business, upon the pains contained in the Act made in the first year of King George the First for preventing tumults and riotous assemblies. God Save the King.&&&&Viva la revolution!
IP Logged
 
Reply #19 - Dec 21st, 2005 at 11:30am

Hagar   Offline
Colonel
My Spitfire Girl
Costa Geriatrica

Posts: 33159
*****
 
Quote:
I am fully aware of that but countries are bound to keep secrets from their allies even in a war that depends on full cooperation.  All I was saying was that the Americans came to Bletchley partle because they wanted in on the act and also as a gesture of trust as their efforts at breaking the German codes hadn't amounted to nearly as much success as the British.

There were two very good reasons the Americans came to Bletchley Park. First the establishment was already set up with the most advanced equipment available for deciphering coded messages. There were probably a lot more Japanese speakers in America (including Japanese Americans) than in Britain or anywhere except Japan. This would obviously be a big advantage in deciphering Japanese codes as they would not have to learn a very complex & difficult language in order to understand what they were doing. The establishment was not set up on a national basis & people from many different nationalities worked alongside each other to achieve a common aim. The defeat of the enemy. This was a great achievement & fine example of international cooperation.
 

...

Founder & Sole Member - Grumpy's Over the Hill Club for Veteran Virtual Aviators
Member of the Fox Four Group

Need help? Try Grumpy's Lair

My photo gallery
IP Logged
 
Reply #20 - Dec 21st, 2005 at 11:43am

myshelf   Offline
Colonel
I love YaBB 1G - SP1!

Posts: 295
*****
 
just as a reminder:

the actual breakthrough in breaking the enigma code came from the polish, who were first evacuated to france after the war broke out, and then on to england.

they brought with them the prototype of the "bomba", the machine that was reproduced many times and stationed in bletchley park to be used to break the daily changing keys.
 

the reasonable man adjusts to his souroundings, while the unreasonable man insists on adjusting his souroundings to him.&&&&therefore all progress is due to the unreasonable man.
IP Logged
 
Reply #21 - Dec 21st, 2005 at 11:51am

Hagar   Offline
Colonel
My Spitfire Girl
Costa Geriatrica

Posts: 33159
*****
 
Quote:
just as a reminder:

the actual breakthrough in breaking the enigma code came from the polish, who were first evacuated to france after the war broke out, and then on to england.

they brought with them the prototype of the "bomba", the machine that was reproduced many times and stationed in bletchley park to be used to break the daily changing keys.

Indeed & this is often forgotten or not realised.

It's also not commonly known that the British & other governments were offered the Enigma machine soon after it was first invented but turned it down as they saw no practical use for it. It was originally intended for commercial use against industrial espionage & available to any large company. Only the Germans took advantage of it for military use.
 

...

Founder & Sole Member - Grumpy's Over the Hill Club for Veteran Virtual Aviators
Member of the Fox Four Group

Need help? Try Grumpy's Lair

My photo gallery
IP Logged
 
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print