A very debatable topic.  I have a Saitek Cyborg 3D (Rumble Force). Its great, does the job, comfortable and if you want to see it and others check out this site - (mine's the second one down from the left):

http://www.saitek.com/uk/prod/joysticks.htm

Ben  8)

Mine's top left.

I'm thinking at this point that Saitek is getting a pretty good nod.  8)

X45 is a great mid-upper level HOTAS setup...and at a great price for what you get.

I'm not one to normally rave about a hardware device...but I will say this:

The Saitek X45 is quite probably the best value for the money in a joystick that is available. The X45 is the third Saitek stick that I've had...previous sticks were a Cyborg 2000 (basically a non-USB version of the 3D Gold) and a Cyborg 3D Gold USB, both previous sticks are still fully functional after many years of abuse and hard gaming.

I already know that the stick that replaces the X45 will be another Saitek...probably the new X52 that is due out later this year.

Thanks for replys guys, but what about the microsoft stick that they show in the game, is it any good?

Hi.

I know that you said "joystick"........ but for realism with most General Aviation aircraft and most commercial aircraft (Airbus being the exception) you might want to consider a yoke instead of a joystick.  Most of these aircraft (except very much older GA aircraft and ultralights) utilize a yoke type control.

I have both........ Logitech FF Wingman Exterme 3d and a CH products USB Pro Yoke.  Both are great..... although some feel that the Logitech is problematic (I have had two over the years..... both have been great). 

For flying a fighter type aircraft.... the joystick is the hands down winner.  But for flying civil aviation craft.... the yoke seems to me to be FAR superior and much more realistic.  When combined with rudder pedals...there is no comparison to the ease of takeoff and landings in the "heavy" aircraft.  (Not to say it's totally "easy".  )

For a test for flying an Airbus ....... use the joystick with the left hand like the real pilots do.  If you are not inherently a "leftie"....... a real eye opener.  Not to mention I think most computer type joysticks are set up for "righties".

As they say....... my $0.02 worth.  Your mileage may vary.  Not available in all locations.  Exclusions may apply  .

best,

...................john

If you want a "left hand" joystick you should look at Saitek's Cyborg sticks. Saitek made it possible for these sticks to be adjusted for most comfortable use...including left hand use.