Simviation Forum
/yabb
Current Flight Simulator Series >> Flight School >> Tail spin
/yabb?num=1299061001

Message started by Beavatron on Mar 2nd, 2011 at 5:16am

Title: Tail spin
Post by Beavatron on Mar 2nd, 2011 at 5:16am
I can take any FS aircraft I have, get it in a turn and cut the power back until it stalls, but I can't get a FS aircraft into a tail spin no matter how hard I try. Is this an oversight by the FS developers? I think they must have designed it so all wing surfaces behave in accordance to the "indicated airspeed" and there's only one point on the aircraft (or no point at all) where speed is measured. In real life, a tail spin results when you're in a tight turn and your inner wing stalls before the outer wing. To recover, in most cases, you neutral all controls and give it full throttle.
Has anybody else noticed that tail spins are impossible in FS? I'm talking about FS9, ... do any FSX users know if they've corrected this?

Title: Re: Tail spin
Post by davysims on Mar 2nd, 2011 at 7:54am
Most aircraft in FS are hard if  not impossible to spin, although there are a few aircraft available that have been made to spin.  I used to have  a Citabria in FS9 that would spin, but I don't remember who made it.

Title: Re: Tail spin
Post by Beavatron on Mar 2nd, 2011 at 9:56am
Hmm... Citabria.  "Airbatic" spelled backwards. Good memories. When I was 14 my neighbor had one. That's what I learned to fly in.

Title: Re: Tail spin
Post by ozzy72 on Mar 2nd, 2011 at 3:22pm
Might I suggest lesson 15 in my old aerobatics tutorial (under the FS2k4 section) http://www.simviation.com/fsdhelp.htm

Title: Re: Tail spin
Post by -Crossfire- on Mar 4th, 2011 at 6:46pm
Just a a side note..... it's just called a spin.  I tail spin would be something different.   ;)

The Realair 172 update can spin with realism sliders set to full.  Freeware i do believe...

Title: Re: Tail spin
Post by Romflyer on Apr 6th, 2011 at 5:30pm
As mentioned earlier there are not many planes in FS that actually will do a spin.....realair 172, C150 (the excellent french one), Long Island classics (Christenson eagle and  Aeronca champ) these are the few noteable ones that come to mind for FS9.

Also, it sounds like your entry method for a spin could use a little......research  ;) try cutting throttle and slowly pulling back on the controls while the plane slows to a stall, when it wont fly anymore then kick a pedal and hold both the control column back and the rudder fully deflected (hold aileron nuetral).......and hold on!  :D keep an eye on the airspeed indicator, it shouldnt rise up much above the stall speed of the AC.........when your ready to recover hit full rudder in the opposite direction of the yaw then lower the nose to break the stall and open up the throttle......... and your back to flying  8-)

Have fun

PS. dont try it below 3000' - 4000'   ::)

Title: Re: Tail spin
Post by EVVFCX on Apr 7th, 2011 at 8:03am
I do like this ;) whats all this about throttle.

My only spin excercise that I had to do before going solo was about 3 1/2 turns and a vertical drop of around 800 feet.

Now then I couldn't put throttle on - I was in a K13 glider  ;D

Title: Re: Tail spin
Post by Grant06 on Apr 7th, 2011 at 6:02pm

Romflyer wrote on Apr 6th, 2011 at 5:30pm:
As mentioned earlier there are not many planes in FS that actually will do a spin.....realair 172, C150 (the excellent french one), Long Island classics (Christenson eagle and  Aeronca champ) these are the few noteable ones that come to mind for FS9.

Also, it sounds like your entry method for a spin could use a little......research  ;) try cutting throttle and slowly pulling back on the controls while the plane slows to a stall, when it wont fly anymore then kick a pedal and hold both the control column back and the rudder fully deflected (hold aileron nuetral).......and hold on!  :D keep an eye on the airspeed indicator, it shouldnt rise up much above the stall speed of the AC.........when your ready to recover hit full rudder in the opposite direction of the yaw then lower the nose to break the stall and open up the throttle......... and your back to flying  8-)

Have fun

PS. dont try it below 3000' - 4000'   ::)


You sir get a free chicken dinner :)
FSX planes will stall but its like the plane has one wing in the middle instead of one on each side. A spin is a product of a "turning stall" power on or off. In reality one wing will ALWAYS stall before the other.
Yup, let the controls go and either add or cut power.
A flight instructer will hopefully exercise this, but prevent a spin.
FSX will not replicate a turning stall.

Simviation Forum » Powered by YaBB 2.5 AE!
YaBB Forum Software © 2000-2010. All Rights Reserved.